Jurors Choose Death In El Cerrito Sibling Slaying
Posted: 5:37 pm PST November 5, 2009Updated: 6:56 am PST November 6, 2009
MARTINEZ, Calif. -- Jurors have decided that Edward Wycoff should be sentenced to death for killing his sister and brother-in-law in their El Cerrito home in 2006. The eight-man, four-woman jury only deliberated for about an hour and 10 minutes before returning with its verdict. Wycoff, a 40-year-old Sacramento-area man, represented himself during trial and testified at length about his reasons for the murders, claiming that he had a right to kill Julie Rogers, 47, and her husband Paul Rogers, 48, because they were "bad people" and were out to get him. He said he planned the murders for weeks and then, on Jan. 31, at about 4:30 a.m., he broke into the family's home at 1467 Rifle Range Road in the El Cerrito hills and stabbed and bludgeoned the couple to death. Two of the couple's three children were home when the attack happened. They hid in a bedroom while Eric Rogers, who was 17 at the time, called 911. Wycoff was convicted on Oct. 27 of two counts of first-degree murder with enhancements for the use of a knife and a wheelbarrow handle. Jurors also found true the special-circumstance allegation that Wycoff committed multiple murders, which made him eligible for the death penalty. Throughout the trial, Wycoff attempted to make jokes, threatened attorneys and claimed that he deserved to be rewarded for the murders, not punished. "Heeeere's Edward," Wycoff said as he entered the courtroom to hear the verdict today. When asked when he would like to be sentenced, Wycoff suggested Dec. 8, his 41st birthday. "He's a frightening individual in the sense that if he believes something is morally right, he's going to take action," Deputy District Attorney Mark Peterson said outside the courtroom. He said the case was unusual for him, since he has never prosecuted a defendant who was "so bold about the reasons why he committed the crimes." "This jury deserved a more dignified and thoughtful trial than the one they got," David Briggs, an attorney who assisted Wycoff throughout the trial, said. He said the jury never heard an articulate plea made on behalf of Wycoff and there was clearly additional evidence that Wycoff never introduced at trial. Although he could not elaborate on what that evidence was, he said that Wycoff mentioned several psychiatrists and psychologists during trial, but the jury never heard from any of them. Eric Rogers said he was disappointed by the verdict. "I wish death wasn't even on the table so it wasn't a decision they had to make," Eric Rogers said. In court, he told the jury that he believed Wycoff was "mentally childish" and should not be sentenced to death for the murders. Earlier this week, Eric Rogers told reporters that he was opposed to the death penalty, as were his parents. Contra Costa County Superior Court Judge John Kennedy, however, ruled that Eric Rogers could not testify about his or his parents' feelings about the death penalty. Douglas Bowman, a longtime friend of Paul Rogers, said that Paul and Julie Rogers were wonderful people who were dearly loved by family, friends and people in the community. "My dad was one of the most intelligent and compassionate people I've ever known," the couple's daughter, who was 12 when her parents were murdered, testified earlier this week. She said he was generous, calm, sincere, caring and open-minded. She said her mother was "also very compassionate and intelligent." "She thought a lot. She was very creative, really kind and thoughtful," the daughter said. "Dead man walking," Wycoff said as bailiffs brought him out of the courtroom in chains. "Watch out. Dead man walking."
Copyright 2009 by KTVU.com and Bay City News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.















What's On RTV
What's On FOX
What's On My 21
The 4 Keys To Women’s Health
G'Day, Mate: Australian Screen Stars
Celebrities Who Served In Military
Check Out The Top 10 Home Updates
The Fashion Blunders Of Katy Perry


